NewMoonMovie.org - Latest Comments in Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

harrypotterisbetter — Sun, 06 Dec 2009 21:12:25 -0000

OMG! i can't believe twilight is winning!
i really don't think that twilight is better than harry potter
it's not that romantic, the firts book was ok....and then
we don't have anything! just books that try to complement the story....
but harry potter! those books are just amazing! it's a great story...the caracters are perfect for each other....what makes twilight so "good" are: Robbert P. and Taylor....but whitout them....twilight is just another romantic movie
harry potter, that movie doesn't need pretty faces to make the movies perfect
twilight doesn't have anything to do next to harry potter!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

bellahermionie — Thu, 06 Aug 2009 20:29:39 -0000

I Love Harry Potter and I Love Twilight
i was never in to the harry potter seris until after i read all the twilight saga books fifty times!!!!! I was tottally obsessed! Then at a friends house i was convinced to try the harry potter seris! it was great just like twilight in a diffrent way! you can compare books that are diffrent! twilight is more of a romance book than Harry potter. I am a thirteen year old who used to Hate reading!!!! Now i love it! i can reread each seris hundreds of times!!! i just wish the seris didn't have to end for each of the seris left me thirsty for more reading! i am obsessed with these 2 seris and by friends call me bella hermionie!!!! much better then my real name!!!!! I love you twilight i love you harry potter each 4 diffrent reasons!!!!!!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

messi2953 — Sun, 19 Jul 2009 19:10:49 -0000

How is Twilight more like real life?

-Vampires
-Werewolves
-Bella jumps off a cliff just to hear someone's voice-that happens every day
-Edward wants marriage whereas Bella wants sex
-The vampires sparkle
-Bella abandons her friends and family for Edward
-A halfvampire, half human child.
-It's clearly because you don't like reading that you found Harry Potter confusing and haven't read Harry Potter.

So much like real life.

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

messi2953 — Sun, 19 Jul 2009 19:04:27 -0000

You idiot. Twilight has no moral values at all-look at it properly and pretend you have some intelligence. Bella is happy to abandon her family and friends for a guy who she's known a year. This is in comparison to the real morals in Harry Potter such as friendship conquers, love conquers, perserverance pays off, and sacrifice for other people also pays off. What does Bella have to give up? Charlie? No. Jacob? No. Her daughter? No. Edward? No. See a pattern here? You must be either stupid or deluded to believe that Twilight has more moral values than Harry Potter. The series isn't about how wizards are good and humans are bad, the whole point is how people insulting the "Muggles" end up getting killed and eventually defeated, so that the true-hearted people can live their lives and co-exist peacefully with Muggles.
Of course, I respect your view but you need a proper argument-what are these values in Twilight? And I have read all four Twilight books multiple times.

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

1mrsedward — Sat, 18 Jul 2009 22:25:46 -0000

1 hav watched every single harry potter movie andi am starting to read them also but i hav read allllllllllll the twilight books and watched the movie!!!!i will be watching new moon the day ti comes out too...

but i luv both the same but 4 different reasons!!!

i hav edward and harry all over my room. my mom says i am obsessed with them and it is probley true....both my friends and i love them..................................

p.s.i luv u edward and harry..xoxxoxxoxxoxoxxoxoxxoxo

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

sasstwi — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 19:32:28 -0000

AMEN. :)

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Punchy - mockingjaymanual.org — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 18:51:22 -0000

Hehe..
Then my life would be so interesting with all the adventure and magic! And romantical with my vampire lover. Yummy.
But my other man wouldn't be a shape shifter / werewolf. He would for sure be a wizard. LOL!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

sasstwi — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 18:37:05 -0000

exactly.
i'm with you on that wish... :)

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

bella425edward4445 — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 11:02:12 -0000

i have read both harry potter and twilight and to tell u the truth i love twilight more because it is about love and horror and just everything i love i will always like harry potter but i am a true twilight fan for life :D

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

cedricsgirl — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 09:38:38 -0000

Okay, obviously Twilight beats Harry Potter on this site because it's a TWILIGHT site. What a joke. This poll is not real at all. There are too many ways in which Harry Potter beats Twilight that it's not funny. Don't get me wrong, I read both books; they're completely opposite books, and shouldn't be put into battle. Harry Potter is in a league of its on, while Twilight only got popular because of the movie, which was abysmal. I read Twilight before the movie. I loved it then, I dislike it now, because of all the fake fans who joined the bandwagon in November of last year.

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Twinutter — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 00:08:21 -0000

oh i love the weasley twins and draco hehehe.

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Twinutter — Sun, 12 Jul 2009 00:07:27 -0000

i k now u were being sarcastic PIMS so was I! :P

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

bad 2 the RathBone[Mar09] — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 11:22:16 -0000

Yes! Genius!

GO TEAM JACKPOT!!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:59:55 -0000

LOL

You've created a monster :) i don't know how you do it :) I have trouble keeping up as it is :)

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

FL95 — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:57:09 -0000

LMAO!!

I needed a break... ch 15 is gonna be hard... so is 16....

*hangs head*

*sighs*

PLUS!! trying to catch up with the READING of the ones that are getting
updated and all the news one people keep talking about!!
For the love of god when does the madness stop!? LOL!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:50:11 -0000

Hold on a sec.....

Why are you not writing??

*shoves FL back down into writers dungeon* lol

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:50:04 -0000

Hold on a sec.....

Why are you not writing??

*shoves FL back down into writers dungeon* lol

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

FL95 — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:46:08 -0000

YEAH!

*blushes*

Thanks man, I'm glad you likey the story!!! ;)

It sucks being us doesn't it!? LOL!

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:36:14 -0000

*accept cookies from the goddess of special shampoos* LOL

So excited about your story :) you're getting a lot of reviews :)

I need coffee too.....am so short tempered lately :)I am on a health kick so it's lack of chocolate :)

Oh well if grey faces can hurl rocks at us we can hurl them back :) lol

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:30:44 -0000

I have this theory that Mr Darcy is actually Rob in disguise....or perhaps Peter :)

No mere mortal would need to cloak themselves in this much secrecy :)

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

FL95 — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:21:08 -0000

NICKY!!!!

Good morning!!!

*hands coffee to Nicky*

Want some?

I know! Freaking alien creatures make me crazy with the way they can
take the time to write books on here, or insult our friends, but not
freaking register....

Will probably get modded or told to play nice, but it's ticking. me. off.

.... pause

*twirls and raises hands in air*

*tosses unicorn cookies to all around me*

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:16:36 -0000

Exactly!!! Why do people think it's one or the other :)

Ikea make 500,000,000 book shelves every year....beacuse the more stories the better :)

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:14:46 -0000

I just shouted at another one down there

*points*

Why write 500 words of rubbish if you can't be bothered joining?? By all means write rubbish if you can :)

How are you??

*bows down to fan fic goddess*

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

Nicnixs :) — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 07:10:37 -0000

You don't sound 20 at all and you're talking absolute crap :)

And that fact that you only read one book out of 7, and it was her first one, means you can't really have an informed opinion on the subject.

If you like darky and twisty, why did you shut the book because the characters seemed a little mean???

But that's for the laugh :) LOL

Re: Harry Potter vs Twilight: Is There Room for Both?

FL95 — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 06:54:38 -0000

LMFAO Effing!

You tell em!

Lali - don't you listen to those stupid grey faces!!! We know who the real dumb a$$es are around here.