-
Website
http://www.newmoonmovie.org/ -
Original page
http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2008/12/is-twilight-too-sexy-for-youngsters/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
-
Top Commenters
-
Popular Threads
- New Photo of Kristen Stewart & Dakota Fanning in ‘The Runaways’
- ‘Remember Me’ Brazilian Teaser Poster & Release Dates
- Cinescape Interview with Kristen Stewart & Taylor Lautner in Mexico
- Twilight Soundtrack Is One Of The Top 25 Soundtracks of the Decade
- Taylor Lautner to Play Pee-Wee Herman in New Movie ?
It is up to the parents for what their children read, and what they think inappropriate or appropriate for them. Yes, in BD there are definitely sex scenes, but obviously they are not detailed. The birthing scene, of course, is quite gory, but, if everyone was so concerned about it, bump the rating up to R.
Personally, I allowed my 10 year old and my 11 year old to read all four of the books. I had read each of them before my kids, and, honestly, most 10+ year olds already know about sex, but don't talk about it with their parents.
The book was very good, and I think they should make it into a movie, and I really could care less for the movie rating. If kids wanted to see the movie, they'd definitely need the permission from a parent or, if they could wait, their parents could buy it on DvD, and they could watch it when they're more mature and more ready for it.
THANKS ALOT FOR SPOILING THE BOOK FOR THOSE OF US WHO HAVE NOT READ IT YET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OH AND BY THE WAY HAVE YOU SEEN WHATS ON TV NOW DAYS ??? unless you block your children from everything in life they will find otu or hear or ever see about things you dont want them too. The local sex education classes the schools offer are do it for you.
in short yes not everything is for everyone but to bash one book that a parent choose for their child is not fair it is the parents that should do their research.
so dont complain about having Breaking Dawn spoiled for you...
just cause kids hear about sex and learn about it doesn't mean that they have to be encouraged to read books that are full of it. Personally i think books with sex are worse than TV/movies cause it leaves your imagination to fill in the gaps. I thought the books were very provocative. If I had kids i would not want them to read books like twilight until they were older(15ish) because kids dont need to get obsessed with sex at a young age.
TRUE BLOOD!!!!! ALL THE WAY!!!! its a good show, but theres like sex in ALMOST EVERY EPISODE IN SEASON 1. they showed BILL'S BUTT!!! I WAS NOT EXPECTING TO SEE THAT!!!!!! and when him and Sookie did it, HE MOANED!!!! THAT WAS NASTY!!!!! GROSS!!! BUT I AM LOOKING FORWARD TO SEASON 2.
I concur. XD
breaking dawn should be made into a movie, the book is one of the best and it ties up all the loose ends =D
i absolutely love it
specially the fact that bella has nessie =D
just like any other movie it may not be approprite but the parents are the ones to decide wether they may see it!
and i also agree that it ties up the entire story and it is completely necessary to make it into a movie! i love all of the books and the movie and it would be great if it ended up being made into a movie!
I concur. XD
breaking dawn should be made into a movie, the book is one of the best and it ties up all the loose ends =D
i absolutely love it
specially the fact that bella has nessie =D
THANKS ALOT FOR SPOILING THE BOOK FOR THOSE OF US WHO HAVE NOT READ IT YET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OH AND BY THE WAY HAVE YOU SEEN WHATS ON TV NOW DAYS ??? unless you block your children from everything in life they will find otu or hear or ever see about things you dont want them too. The local sex education classes the schools offer are do it for you.
in short yes not everything is for everyone but to bash one book that a parent choose for their child is not fair it is the parents that should do their research.
just like any other movie it may not be approprite but the parents are the ones to decide wether they may see it!
and i also agree that it ties up the entire story and it is completely necessary to make it into a movie! i love all of the books and the movie and it would be great if it ended up being made into a movie!
I understand that with all the gore and sex scenes that Breaking Dawn will not be suitable for younger people but if they don't think it will be suitable then why dont they raise it to a 15 (UK). In my opinion Breaking Dawn is one of the best books in the series so I really wouldn't want the movie to not be made!!
Don't punish the people the series was demographically pointed at!!
As a parent, I view things before deciding whether or not to allow my children to view them as well. I find that there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with the Twilight saga as a whole, with Breaking Dawn, or with the premise of making Breaking Dawn into a movie. It will be up to parents to decide whether or not to let their children see the movie.
Honestly, there is MUCH MUCH worse on prime-time network tv, in music videos, and even things going on on the school bus, than any content of these books or movies.
stephenie never said it was for young audiences.
there go parents again trying to put the blame on someone else for their child's problems.
I understand that with all the gore and sex scenes that Breaking Dawn will not be suitable for younger people but if they don't think it will be suitable then why dont they raise it to a 15 (UK). In my opinion Breaking Dawn is one of the best books in the series so I really wouldn't want the movie to not be made!!
Don't punish the people the series was demographically pointed at!!
I'm thirteen and my whole year has read every book and seen the movie millions of times !
If they make breaking dawn a rating higher than 15 i won't get to see it
don't trash the books and don't trash the movies
I concur. XD
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up
As a parent, I view things before deciding whether or not to allow my children to view them as well. I find that there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with the Twilight saga as a whole, with Breaking Dawn, or with the premise of making Breaking Dawn into a movie. It will be up to parents to decide whether or not to let their children see the movie.
Honestly, there is MUCH MUCH worse on prime-time network tv, in music videos, and even things going on on the school bus, than any content of these books or movies.
It is up to the parents for what their children read, and what they think inappropriate or appropriate for them. Yes, in BD there are definitely sex scenes, but obviously they are not detailed. The birthing scene, of course, is quite gory, but, if everyone was so concerned about it, bump the rating up to R.
Personally, I allowed my 10 year old and my 11 year old to read all four of the books. I had read each of them before my kids, and, honestly, most 10+ year olds already know about sex, but don't talk about it with their parents.
The book was very good, and I think they should make it into a movie, and I really could care less for the movie rating. If kids wanted to see the movie, they'd definitely need the permission from a parent or, if they could wait, their parents could buy it on DvD, and they could watch it when they're more mature and more ready for it.
breaking dawn should be made into a movie, the book is one of the best and it ties up all the loose ends =D
i absolutely love it
specially the fact that bella has nessie =D
stephenie never said it was for young audiences.
there go parents again trying to put the blame on someone else for their child's problems.
And kids = 17 and below, please please please "be safe"
~Sara Bella
The last book is way inappropriate for a movie. I dont know about you but i dont want to watch sex for the whole movie. I think it would be fine if they changed the movie up a bit. Gave us something more interesting to watch instead.
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up"
Wow ... I doubt you're 21 rofl (rolling on the floor laughing). I disagree and I personally think you stopped reading Breaking Dawn when you got to the part about Isle Esme. Re-read then re-post please.
~Sara Bella
just like any other movie it may not be approprite but the parents are the ones to decide wether they may see it!
and i also agree that it ties up the entire story and it is completely necessary to make it into a movie! i love all of the books and the movie and it would be great if it ended up being made into a movie!
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up
Inappropriate....pfft!
I guess I do have to say that I did over exaggerate by saying the whole movie would be like a porno. and that we do see sex on tv like all the time. I am not saying that books are bad or filled with it. Im just saying that I would rather watch something else on the movie screen. I also agree that it is the parents choice to let your kid read and watch it.
So Angela I guess you did kind change my mind a little bit
THANKS ALOT FOR SPOILING THE BOOK FOR THOSE OF US WHO HAVE NOT READ IT YET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OH AND BY THE WAY HAVE YOU SEEN WHATS ON TV NOW DAYS ??? unless you block your children from everything in life they will find otu or hear or ever see about things you dont want them too. The local sex education classes the schools offer are do it for you.
in short yes not everything is for everyone but to bash one book that a parent choose for their child is not fair it is the parents that should do their research.
And kids = 17 and below, please please please "be safe"
~Sara Bella
also to those who are worried about the sexual content... well there probably won't be much cuz there are really only a few sex scenes and tho book doesn't have any detail(except that Edward bangs her too hard the first time) so the movie most likely won't have too much more no matter how much i wish it would :(
The last book is way inappropriate for a movie. I dont know about you but i dont want to watch sex for the whole movie. I think it would be fine if they changed the movie up a bit. Gave us something more interesting to watch instead.
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up"
Wow ... I doubt you're 21 rofl (rolling on the floor laughing). I disagree and I personally think you stopped reading Breaking Dawn when you got to the part about Isle Esme. Re-read then re-post please.
~Sara Bella
I'm sure it will be very romantic and yet still tasteful. Besides, kids already see enough of sex in daytime television when their mom watch those daytime soaps.
Don't punish the people the series was demographically pointed at!!
eclipse in 2012
and breaking dawn in 2013
People are blowing this way out of proportion.
are you serious
i already knew about New Moon but am i really going to wait 3 years til Eclipse and 4 til Breaking Dawn
THAT WOULD REALLY SUCK
but i'm pretty sure that you're wrong because my friend said that New Moon and Eclipse would be back-to-back and SnapSnap said it too
and if Eclipse is coming sooner that you say then Breaking Dawn probably will too
As a parent, I view things before deciding whether or not to allow my children to view them as well. I find that there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with the Twilight saga as a whole, with Breaking Dawn, or with the premise of making Breaking Dawn into a movie. It will be up to parents to decide whether or not to let their children see the movie.
Honestly, there is MUCH MUCH worse on prime-time network tv, in music videos, and even things going on on the school bus, than any content of these books or movies.
Plus all of this hype is the same as it was with the Harry Potter Books in regards to the kids ages vs the content in the latter books. Any kid that is 10-12 yrs old now will be probably close to 15-17 yrs old minmum by the time Breaking Dawn would even be out as a movie. Are they still going to be considered too young to see it????
stephenie never said it was for young audiences.
there go parents again trying to put the blame on someone else for their child's problems.
Plus all of this hype is the same as it was with the Harry Potter Books in regards to the kids ages vs the content in the latter books. Any kid that is 10-12 yrs old now will be probably close to 15-17 yrs old minmum by the time Breaking Dawn would even be out as a movie. Are they still going to be considered too young to see it????
I'm sure it will be very romantic and yet still tasteful. Besides, kids already see enough of sex in daytime television when their mom watch those daytime soaps.
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up
It is up to the parents for what their children read, and what they think inappropriate or appropriate for them. Yes, in BD there are definitely sex scenes, but obviously they are not detailed. The birthing scene, of course, is quite gory, but, if everyone was so concerned about it, bump the rating up to R.
Personally, I allowed my 10 year old and my 11 year old to read all four of the books. I had read each of them before my kids, and, honestly, most 10+ year olds already know about sex, but don't talk about it with their parents.
The book was very good, and I think they should make it into a movie, and I really could care less for the movie rating. If kids wanted to see the movie, they'd definitely need the permission from a parent or, if they could wait, their parents could buy it on DvD, and they could watch it when they're more mature and more ready for it.
I think all the books are amazing, the movies just dont have to follow them to the tee
everyone knows that their children know about sex, my brother(12 yrs old now)knew all about sex and stuff like that like 3 or 4 years ago
and i'm pretty sure that 10 yr olds even knew about sex and all that 'adult stuff' even in the '60s
i'm all for making the movie. i think Stephanie Meyer is a genious with writing and it would be an insult to many if Breaking Dawn was not made a movie
just for the record:
ANYONE THAT DISAGREES WITH ME IS AN IDIOT
:)
And kids = 17 and below, please please please "be safe"
~Sara Bella
The last book is way inappropriate for a movie. I dont know about you but i dont want to watch sex for the whole movie. I think it would be fine if they changed the movie up a bit. Gave us something more interesting to watch instead.
I do believe that they should make it a movie, to finish the series and wrap it all up"
Wow ... I doubt you're 21 rofl (rolling on the floor laughing). I disagree and I personally think you stopped reading Breaking Dawn when you got to the part about Isle Esme. Re-read then re-post please.
~Sara Bella
I'm sure it will be very romantic and yet still tasteful. Besides, kids already see enough of sex in daytime television when their mom watch those daytime soaps.
Plus all of this hype is the same as it was with the Harry Potter Books in regards to the kids ages vs the content in the latter books. Any kid that is 10-12 yrs old now will be probably close to 15-17 yrs old minmum by the time Breaking Dawn would even be out as a movie. Are they still going to be considered too young to see it????
Did you know that in Kill Bill the fighting scenes that are in black in white are so because Quentin Tarantino had to find a way to reduce the amount of blood in his movie or they were going to give him an 'X' rating. Since they were more concerned that there was too much 'red' he changed the picture to black and white. Sooooo... black and white birth scene? I know, call Tarantino!!
Too true.
Did you know that in Kill Bill the fighting scenes that are in black in white are so because Quentin Tarantino had to find a way to reduce the amount of blood in his movie or they were going to give him an 'X' rating. Since they were more concerned that there was too much 'red' he changed the picture to black and white. Sooooo... black and white birth scene? I know, call Tarantino!!
So back to sex. The discretion is up to the parents. Sex isn't a dirty thing or a bad thing. Maybe if adults didn't make it such a taboo, kids would actually listen to them and have more realistic expectations (like knowing that sex is more than physical gratification and you should be responsible). Teens have urges and there is no way they will go away just by avoiding the subject and shielding them from it. Like someone said already: "at least they waited until they got married". Also by not educating themselves, they end up with an unplanned pregnancy. As for the movie, really, they can edit as much as they want. So the issues shouldn't be to make it into a movie or not.
Did you know that in Kill Bill the fighting scenes that are in black in white are so because Quentin Tarantino had to find a way to reduce the amount of blood in his movie or they were going to give him an 'X' rating. Since they were more concerned that there was too much 'red' he changed the picture to black and white. Sooooo... black and white birth scene? I know, call Tarantino!!
Inappropriate....pfft!
Too true.
I guess I do have to say that I did over exaggerate by saying the whole movie would be like a porno. and that we do see sex on tv like all the time. I am not saying that books are bad or filled with it. Im just saying that I would rather watch something else on the movie screen. I also agree that it is the parents choice to let your kid read and watch it.
So Angela I guess you did kind change my mind a little bit
I think all the books are amazing, the movies just dont have to follow them to the tee
So back to sex. The discretion is up to the parents. Sex isn't a dirty thing or a bad thing. Maybe if adults didn't make it such a taboo, kids would actually listen to them and have more realistic expectations (like knowing that sex is more than physical gratification and you should be responsible). Teens have urges and there is no way they will go away just by avoiding the subject and shielding them from it. Like someone said already: "at least they waited until they got married". Also by not educating themselves, they end up with an unplanned pregnancy. As for the movie, really, they can edit as much as they want. So the issues shouldn't be to make it into a movie or not.
So back to sex. The discretion is up to the parents. Sex isn't a dirty thing or a bad thing. Maybe if adults didn't make it such a taboo, kids would actually listen to them and have more realistic expectations (like knowing that sex is more than physical gratification and you should be responsible). Teens have urges and there is no way they will go away just by avoiding the subject and shielding them from it. Like someone said already: "at least they waited until they got married". Also by not educating themselves, they end up with an unplanned pregnancy. As for the movie, really, they can edit as much as they want. So the issues shouldn't be to make it into a movie or not.
eclipse in 2012
and breaking dawn in 2013
People are blowing this way out of proportion.
Inappropriate....pfft!
I guess I do have to say that I did over exaggerate by saying the whole movie would be like a porno. and that we do see sex on tv like all the time. But it would still be nice to have the movie not rated R
I think all the books are amazing, the movies just dont have to follow them to the tee
The thing is...by making the rating PG-13, if they could find a way, it would probably make the movie kind-of...suck...
eclipse in 2012
and breaking dawn in 2013
People are blowing this way out of proportion.
i never even thought about 'happily ever after' that way but you're so right
ha ha ha
In the book Meyer doesn't actually say Edward and Bella had sex,she just puts the idea in your head so you can run with it,and the only proof that they did have sex was when Nessie was born.
In the book Meyer doesn't actually say Edward and Bella had sex,she just puts the idea in your head so you can run with it,and the only proof that they did have sex was when Nessie was born.
so dont complain about having Breaking Dawn spoiled for you...
just cause kids hear about sex and learn about it doesn't mean that they have to be encouraged to read books that are full of it. Personally i think books with sex are worse than TV/movies cause it leaves your imagination to fill in the gaps. I thought the books were very provocative. If I had kids i would not want them to read books like twilight until they were older(15ish) because kids dont need to get obsessed with sex at a young age.
*A new but defensive fan
*A new but defensive fan
In the book Meyer doesn't actually say Edward and Bella had sex,she just puts the idea in your head so you can run with it,and the only proof that they did have sex was when Nessie was born.
I did not mean any of the books in particular, but I meant it more towards Breaking Dawn than the others. Even though it's a part of life and I should not have to always protect my daughter, I don't think she'd be ready for the fourth book.
so dont complain about having Breaking Dawn spoiled for you...
just cause kids hear about sex and learn about it doesn't mean that they have to be encouraged to read books that are full of it. Personally i think books with sex are worse than TV/movies cause it leaves your imagination to fill in the gaps. I thought the books were very provocative. If I had kids i would not want them to read books like twilight until they were older(15ish) because kids dont need to get obsessed with sex at a young age.
*A new but defensive fan
bella and edward dont exactyly have sex till breaking dawn which is like 2 more movies away..so they can worry about the age thing rating THEN....
also its the parents choice whether to let their young children see the movie or even read the book for that matter.....anywaiiz most kids under 10 probly wont understand it so yer...its just a typical love story like any other love movie ...like the titanic movie twilight is like that minus the boat....two peple who cant be together fall in love....and their relationship evolves through each book ..
sex is a part of life ..they gunna wanna no sooner or later....in this day n age preferbably sooner lol
bella and edward dont exactyly have sex till breaking dawn which is like 2 more movies away..so they can worry about the age thing rating THEN....
also its the parents choice whether to let their young children see the movie or even read the book for that matter.....anywaiiz most kids under 10 probly wont understand it so yer...its just a typical love story like any other love movie ...like the titanic movie twilight is like that minus the boat....two peple who cant be together fall in love....and their relationship evolves through each book ..
sex is a part of life ..they gunna wanna no sooner or later....in this day n age preferbably sooner lol
bella and edward dont exactyly have sex till breaking dawn which is like 2 more movies away..so they can worry about the age thing rating THEN....
also its the parents choice whether to let their young children see the movie or even read the book for that matter.....anywaiiz most kids under 10 probly wont understand it so yer...its just a typical love story like any other love movie ...like the titanic movie twilight is like that minus the boat....two peple who cant be together fall in love....and their relationship evolves through each book ..
sex is a part of life ..they gunna wanna no sooner or later....in this day n age preferbably sooner lol
I did not mean any of the books in particular, but I meant it more towards Breaking Dawn than the others. Even though it's a part of life and I should not have to always protect my daughter, I don't think she'd be ready for the fourth book.
I did not mean any of the books in particular, but I meant it more towards Breaking Dawn than the others. Even though it's a part of life and I should not have to always protect my daughter, I don't think she'd be ready for the fourth book.
oh and I don't love Edward.
oh and I don't love Edward.
oh and I don't love Edward.
BRING ON THE ACTION IN Breaking Dawn THE MOVIE!!!
BRING ON THE ACTION IN Breaking Dawn THE MOVIE!!!
BRING ON THE ACTION IN Breaking Dawn THE MOVIE!!!
Plus, regarding the breaking dawn, they'll just make it like the book - a kiss leading to the bed and stop the scene there. Same for one or two times after Renesmee is born.. I feel like going to the writer of the article or whoever came up with that and going DUHHHH . Sure it might spoil the movie for some people but that's how it is in the book anyway and it would end up being a porn film if they included the sex scenes as sex is.
Plus, regarding the breaking dawn, they'll just make it like the book - a kiss leading to the bed and stop the scene there. Same for one or two times after Renesmee is born.. I feel like going to the writer of the article or whoever came up with that and going DUHHHH . Sure it might spoil the movie for some people but that's how it is in the book anyway and it would end up being a porn film if they included the sex scenes as sex is.
its so easy to sneak into a movie or to lie about your age
especially since this generation of teenagers has a wide range in heights and sizes just makes it easierlike my friend is older than me but shes like WAY shorter and looks 10 yrs old and my other friend is 11 but she looks like shes at least 13 and im 13(almost 14) and people look at me and think im like 15 or 16 one person actually thought i was 17
so rating the movie R (when its just like a lot of PG13 movies) isn't going to make any difference because teens are really smart, creative, and resorceful when it comes to something we really really REALLY want
Plus, regarding the breaking dawn, they'll just make it like the book - a kiss leading to the bed and stop the scene there. Same for one or two times after Renesmee is born.. I feel like going to the writer of the article or whoever came up with that and going DUHHHH . Sure it might spoil the movie for some people but that's how it is in the book anyway and it would end up being a porn film if they included the sex scenes as sex is.
Idiots. theres way worse things on t.v to watch now 'n days. &
if they end up not making that movie because a little sex or it turns rated R ill pissseddddd!
Idiots. theres way worse things on t.v to watch now 'n days. &
if they end up not making that movie because a little sex or it turns rated R ill pissseddddd!
Idiots. theres way worse things on t.v to watch now 'n days. &
if they end up not making that movie because a little sex or it turns rated R ill pissseddddd!
OR THERE WILL BE HELL TO PAY
I SWEAR IT
AND IF FOR WHATEVER REASON ONE OF THE BOOKS ISNT MADE INTO A MOVIE I SWEAR I WILL FORM AN ARMY
IM NOT EVEN KIDDING
I REALLY WANT THOSE MOVIES
parents and adults all over the country(mabey all over the world) are freaking out because of AGE
but thats STUPID
i mean sure its a little too much for 8 yr olds
but other than that parents should be considering their childs MATURITY LEVEL as in mature thinking and if the child is responsible enough not to go out having sex with everyone in town just because they read a tiny bit about a tiny bit of sex
*although i wouldn't mind seeing a little nudity of Edward because hes just SO HOT ;)*
TRUE BLOOD!!!!! ALL THE WAY!!!! its a good show, but theres like sex in ALMOST EVERY EPISODE IN SEASON 1. they showed BILL'S BUTT!!! I WAS NOT EXPECTING TO SEE THAT!!!!!! and when him and Sookie did it, HE MOANED!!!! THAT WAS NASTY!!!!! GROSS!!! BUT I AM LOOKING FORWARD TO SEASON 2.
By the time the movie is made, all the 10 y.o's reading the books will be around 13 or maybe 14. And by that time... EVERYONE knows about it. Even stuff your parents think that you dont know....
Theres enough blood and gore in the Saw movies, and they're MA +15 in Australia.
Theres sex on TV and its only ever M or MA +15.
They dont have to show "all of it". Its pretty obvious that they could just skip it in the movie. Its not like some big mystery whats going to happen.
We have books in the school library where a girl has sex with her brother... that worse than Edward and Bella...
By the time the movie is made, all the 10 y.o's reading the books will be around 13 or maybe 14. And by that time... EVERYONE knows about it. Even stuff your parents think that you dont know....
Theres enough blood and gore in the Saw movies, and they're MA +15 in Australia.
Theres sex on TV and its only ever M or MA +15.
They dont have to show "all of it". Its pretty obvious that they could just skip it in the movie. Its not like some big mystery whats going to happen.
We have books in the school library where a girl has sex with her brother... that worse than Edward and Bella...
and think that the 10 years old and below have the likeness to read the thick books? i think, they focus more on their toys and baby stuffs. haha.
and think that the 10 years old and below have the likeness to read the thick books? i think, they focus more on their toys and baby stuffs. haha.
I'm thirteen and my whole year has read every book and seen the movie millions of times !
If they make breaking dawn a rating higher than 15 i won't get to see it
its not really about age (as long as they're 10+)
its more an issue of how maturely and responsibly a person will be able to respond to reading about sex
Yes, the sex scenes in BD are not appropriate for some younger kids. The movie rating SHOULD go up a bit. Because the birth scene is pretty gory. But I think that teens who're fine with sex can and should read the books.
Yes, the sex scenes in BD are not appropriate for some younger kids. The movie rating SHOULD go up a bit. Because the birth scene is pretty gory. But I think that teens who're fine with sex can and should read the books.
i think your honest opinion sucks except for the last 2 sentances
and they started sex ed in 6th grade when i was eleven
and i and everyone else whose not a complete retard would agree with me that sex ed was and is a LOT worse than Breaking Dawn
are you an idiot
there isn't anything "limited" about their awareness
in case you haven't noticed, THIS IS THE 21st CENTURY and literally EVERY BODY knows about and is aware of all the sex going on in the world around them
and just for the record: its more 'dangerous' if they they know about sex without actually KNOWING about it
-the whole issue of abortion and whether it's justified to save a woman's life
-the fact that Edward, Carlisle and Jacob are all willing to give Bella an abortion against her will
-Edward suggesting that Jacob should impregnate his wife...and possibly share her- almost like a child custody agreement
In my opinion, these ideas are just too mature for most children and young teens. As for the movie, they should make the movie true to the book and not water it down...there are plenty of Twighlight fans out there old enough to see R rated movies.
i've never really thought about those issues as not age appropriate
but thats probably cuz they ARE appropriate enough for MY age
but those really are above the 9 and 10 yr olds
but i don't really think that it should be rated R becouse i've read that book twice already and theres really nothing 'R-ish' about it
oh- except for when Bella is totally naked looking at her bruises in the mirror after that first night
and during Renessmees birth
but thats not really fair to rate it R because those are seriously THE ONLY PARTS that would be worthy of the R and they only really last a couple of seconds really
:{
THATS NOT FAIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hmph
grr
they are both pretty good looking
and people around their age are always looking forward to sex
and they're actors
actors love sex
actors are like some of the biggest whores on the planet
I don't think that the Twilight Saga should only be for young adults, it should be for everyone who is mature enough to read it.
:)
The thing is...by making the rating PG-13, if they could find a way, it would probably make the movie kind-of...suck...
i think 10 is a great age for girls to be reading the saga
the problem is that your an adult and you don't know ANYTHING about todays 10 yr olds
i'm 13 yrs old- i know a lot of 10 year olds and i think they are totally fine reading the saga- ESPECIALLY Breaking Dawn- because the 10 yr olds of this day and age are a lot more mature than when you were a kid and the REAL issue that no adults seem to notice is this ......
"Are the children MATURE enough to read these books?"
"Will the children react maturely and responsibly to reading about love and sex in these books?"
if someone isn't mature and responsible enough, then they shouldn't be allowed to read the Twilight Saga yet. but if they are then they shouldn't be discouraged or stopped from reading these books. but make sure you actually know your kid before you ban the books, because it would be a waste to keep your children from this interesting and brilliantly written saga
and there are only 2 parts that only last a couple seconds in Breaking Dawn that could make it rated R
i don't really think thats fair
actually thats very very UNfair
and i still think your stupid
and so does everyone 13 or younger who saw what you said
so a lot of people think that