NewMoonMovie.org - Latest Comments in Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

!!!!!! — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 00:12:47 -0000

ma bro saw da movie 2day..he said edward proposed!! i didnt get 2 go not fair!!

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Bree x — Thu, 15 Oct 2009 15:52:47 -0000

Hey does anyone know where I can get an audition form from for breaking dawn??
Plz reply Bree x

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

cullenwannabe1 — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 21:45:22 -0000

well, the thing is, you can't control who you fall in love with, theerefore bella fell in love with them both.
Humans. tsk, tsk, tsk......

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

xxxAbixxxWolfexxx — Thu, 14 May 2009 09:02:26 -0000

This poster of Bella curled up on the forest floor would be absolutly perfect for the dvd cover. New Moon is all about Bella's depression at loosing Edward and the main thing we relate to setting-wise is the forest. Edwards home is set in the forest, its where the vampire secret came out, where they hunt...It's perfect and shows just the right amount of vulnerability. No rain, no water, no life. No sky, no light, no hope. But the fetal potion shows us she will get up and fight! xxxxx

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 17:33:53 -0000

No.

She would have moved past Edward in time *if* Alice never returned. Why? Because she thought Edward didn't want her. Edward didn't croak... he didn't get kidnapped... he didn't move to an out-of-state college. HE LEFT HER.

Bella's time with Jake was allowing her to become a whole person again. Her dad, her school friends, no one even came close to Jacob's progress with her. She was almost to the point where she was going to let herself be with Jake. It didn't take her long to even reach that point... because Jacob *is* that soulmate in a world without Edward.

She "uses" him because he is so good at being her personal sun... and it's partly *because* of Jacob that she wouldn't kill herself over Edward. She didn't cliffdive to kill herself, she did it because it was something reckless to hear Edward's voice. She fought to reach the surface, she didn't just let the tide take her willingly. When she was on the brink of death she was only accepting it because she didn't have a choice, she knew she was drowning. After this jump... she's in the truck with Jacob and he has his arm around her. Does Edward's voice say "Don't get too close to him" ?? No. He says "Be happy." This is her hallucinating heart speaking to her in his voice. Her HEART was telling her to be happy, even without Edward. Which is why she stiffened up then, because it freaked her out. A happy life without Edward? She thought it was impossible. But little by little Jacob was proving her wrong... he was helping her to help herself. She was indeed living without Edward... in fact she was learning to be happy again. Her hallucinations weren't yelling at her anymore for being stupid... they were encouraging her to be happy. She was on the mend. She was finally moving on.

Edward on the other hand would be losing out on his soulmate... so do I like this scenario of Edward staying away and Jake and Bella being happy together? No. I want all three of them to be happy, and there is only one way for that to happen, and it does.

When Edward comes back in New Moon there is no hope for her... she knows Edward's true feelings and why he left. *THEN* is when she knows she truly can't live without Edward. The only window of time Jake had to win her over was in New Moon before Alice came back. But Alice ruined it so... lol. It's a good thing her and Jake didn't get in any deeper because Jacob's pain would have been ten times worse.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 16:36:26 -0000

Thank you!! This is what I've been trying to explain for like... the last six months, lol.

The Bella that fell in love with Jake was a Bella that didn't have Edward. When Edward comes back she cannot force herself to give Jacob up in Eclipse, even though Edward wants her to let him go. She had the choice to dilute Jacob's feelings easier in time (she knew how Jacob felt, even in New Moon) but she didn't. She pursued their friendship even further, again, KNOWING that Jacob is in love with her. It wa selfish of her, but she wasn't *trying* to hurt anyone, therefore I can't fault her. Stephenie Meyer says Bella didn't give Jacob up because she was in love with him as well and denied it. Denying it made it easier to live with. In the end all three of them hurt each other in different ways, they're all victims and perpetrators.

Two soulmates for two different lives.. if Edward were out of the picture Jacob would be hers. That's what Stephenie is trying to show the reader when Bella kisses him and sees the potential life she was giving up. Never once does she ever consider Jacob *over* Edward... EVER.

I still think Jacob suffered the most overall, though. I really like the kid, so I can't help but have immense compassion for him.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 16:17:45 -0000

I didn't cry at all when Edward left. In fact I was angry because he was being overdramatic and going overboard (as he so often tends to do.) I love Edward, don't get me wrong, but this was a huge mistake. This one bad choice started so much trouble and he ended up hurting not only Bella, but himself and Jacob as well.

The only time I've cried is like you--at the end of Eclipse. I cried at work all night long off and on. It was pretty pathetic... but I felt Jacob's pain in Eclipse and I felt it in Breaking Dawn too. The kid is the most real person in the whole story to me. My compassion lies with him much more often than Bella or Edward.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 15:59:46 -0000

I disagree. I don't see why a lot of people don't seem to understand this...

It's not that Jacob needs her to choose him for his own needs. He loves her and of course he wants to win out over Edward but above all else Jake wants Bella to choose him so she will live out her human life and not become a vampire. In his eyes becoming a vampire is a fate worse than death and he tells her this. He's a werewolf, he instinctively hates vampires---how would you feel if the the girl you fell in love with when her leech abandoned her still chose him in the end despite knowing she loves you as well? Have compassion, people. I mean my god. They were all at fault at one point or another, they are all victims at one point or another. Jacob should not take the brunt of any blame here. His motivations were driven by true love, he has a strong spirit and I love that about him.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 15:48:39 -0000

As Jacob says in Breaking Dawn "Make Bella see reason? What universe do you live in?"

He doesn't FORCE her. He just wants her to realize what they both already know because he wants, above all else, to SAVE her life. He has to use a sly tactic or two, but it's because Bella doesn't see reason like she should, even Stephenie Meyer says she doesn't think of the consequences of her actions and Jacob is not a bad person at all, he just wants her to know she has a choice. To him, becoming a vampire is worse than death, and especially being the vampire's natural enemy, that hatred is instinctively bone-deep.

Jacob's entire motivation is his true love for her. How can you fault the kid for sticking to his guns? I find it quite admirable. He knows one day soon she will be one of them and he can't stand it. By the end of Eclipse he accepts that she will never be his. Can you imagine how that must have felt? People have no compassion. Their love triangle was a tragedy with no villains, only victims.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

My Jacob — Thu, 07 May 2009 15:36:18 -0000

Exactly. Thank you.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

mschicklet — Tue, 05 May 2009 07:56:40 -0000

Probably the best Bella poster circulating right now. I love the "he's gone"

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

JacOb! woOpwoOp! — Thu, 23 Apr 2009 04:03:22 -0000

Even though Bella is being quite selfish to want both Men by her side I understand why she does. I mean like someone said in the past comments She Is only Human after all. Im sure all of us have had this experience before when we want two guys at the same time so yea..

I am just glad that Jacob is happy in the end because if he didnt get his deserved Happy Ending I wouldve been really mad! Everyone needs a happy ending coz without Love life is pointless.

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

JacOb! woOpwoOp! — Thu, 23 Apr 2009 03:54:37 -0000

Well I think that Jacob is the bestest friend anyone could ever have. I mean do you know any guy who would rather hurt his feelings than hurt yours? A guy who would sacrifice his life for you even though he knew that you love sumone else?
You gotta admit that if Edward didnt exist Bella and Jacob wouldve been great together. I reckon that no one should blame Jacob for loving Bella because she is meant to be his soul mate after all, but Edward comes in the story & everythin gets all muddled up. Im not sayin I dnt like Edward or anything coz he is great and he loves Bella which is the mst important thng i gues.

I am kinda mad at Bella once i think about it because she is just so selfish when she wants both Jacob AND Edward as company. I mean if she loves Jacob why cant she just pretend not to need him so much when she is around Edward and vise versa because when she talks about Jacob in front of Edward.. or when she talks about Edward infront of Jacob this kills them both.

When I was reading the Saga I loved Edward but I have always had a soft spot for Jacob because I know what its like doin wat he does. In BD Edward kinda realize how Bella needs Jacob and how Jacob needs Bella.. He knew that if he died when he shouldve that Bella and Jacob wouldve lived happily eva after as they should.

I love them both but Jacob is definitely my favourite out of the two. If you like Edward better then I dnt hav a problem with that coz obviously he is the leading man. One thing though I hope that all the Twilight Fans out there would see how Jacob is just as important as Edward.. I mean he did help Bella through her darkest moments in NM and even turned his back on his pack in BD in order to save her life.

xoxoxo

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Twinutter — Wed, 22 Apr 2009 21:28:01 -0000

what do you mean?

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Twinutter — Wed, 22 Apr 2009 21:23:46 -0000

Aw man, she loves him as more than a friend? that sucks. (yeah i havent read eclipse yet, im a noob.) so should i be forewarned of some hating coming from me while reading it? lol

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

team FEATHERS/ JENESMEE!! — Mon, 20 Apr 2009 22:18:08 -0000

if you read my comment i said i "was so mad at bella"
its just a book anyways...

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Z.J. Cullen — Sun, 19 Apr 2009 16:19:56 -0000

I honestly think that New Moon will be better than Twilight...It's just a feeling. Everyone in the cast says it's gonna be ALOT BETTER b/c of the new effects and they have better makeup for the vampires, ect. I really hope they're right...

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Holly Maiden — Sun, 19 Apr 2009 00:42:38 -0000

I have a different perspective...I saw the movie first, then started reading the books. I absolutely LOVED the movie, and after I read Twilight, thought that the movie was pretty accurate, considering how much detail was in the book. Maybe I would've seen it differently if I had read the book first...but I thought Rob & Kristen were BOTH perfect for their characters! The movie's will not be exactly like the books b/c they have to add some Hollywood appeal -- that's a given. The differences that were evident didn't matter so much to me b/c I was still completely drawn in to the chemistry of this couple....the unconditional love.
I love Bella's character, too -- she IS human...questioning her love for two different people. That could happen to any human if the moment presented itself! It is my understanding that Edward will ONLY be drawn to Bella because that is who he is destined to be with, and Bella IS questioning b/c she IS a human. She was hurt when he left, and became vulnerable to Jacob. Try and put yourself in her place, gals! The good news is that she CHOOSES the right one in the end!
I LOVE Twilight!!!

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

gyukgykuy — Sat, 18 Apr 2009 13:03:18 -0000

i agree he does force her to kiss him and even though she actually kisses him back in the end, she still never actually wants him or kiss him. i like your theory on the 'craved a different set of arms' i hope thats true lol

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

gyukgykuy — Sat, 18 Apr 2009 12:58:31 -0000

i dont really like jacob but only bec\ause he kept pushing for bella to be with him. i think theyre best as friends but nothing more. she did love jacob but i think she was fine with him as a friend and she just loved edward so much more and i wish she didnt really love jacob but then its good that it says its bc of renesmee lol

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

person — Fri, 17 Apr 2009 16:49:02 -0000

it was all because of renesmee until jacob became a wolf his feeligs were still in crush mode but bella was always meant to have renesmee so they couldnt live without eachother they explained it in BD

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Nothin'ButTheRain — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 01:25:12 -0000

Maybe I'm just cold hearted or something, but I never felt sorry for Jake. Jake did try REALLY hard though. But it just made me sad to think that he's trying to take Bella away from Edward. Edward had been alone for SO long and he's finally able to be with someone. It just turns out that that someone has a knack for getting caught in the middle of trouble.
" knowing how he feels about her, but always absurdly happy when he's there and wanting him around." Well, she's pregnant. Even though the thing was literally killing her from the inside she loved it. After all, one reason she wanted to keep it was because it was Edwards. I don't think she shouldn't be allowed to be happy. Jake really annoyed me in Breaking Dawn. He complained WAY too much. I mean, she was already married and felt the need to mope around. Anyways, while Edward was kind of having his little nervous breakdown, Bella needed someone to be with her. Jake was always known as her personal sun and that's what she needed. I think he should have just gotten over himself and let HER be happy without her having to feel guilty.
Haha! The birth I wish wasn't in Jacob's POV. Especially when it got to the point where he said that he's pictured her many times naked and whatnot but having a bruised belly doesn't do it for him.

That's true. Edward definantly has had a longer expeience at being a teenager, but Bella never really acted like one a whole lot. Jake was the only one who actually seemed to act his age. They all went through weird stages in their life, Bella being caught up in the middle of both. I try to keep an open mind while reading about Jake and what he's gone through. It's just too hard when he's being really annoying and douchey sometimes. Haha! But, whatever. The series is over, everyone had their happy ending and yet some people just don't face that fact. I mean all the Jacob/Bella shippers. Oh well...

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

tweeter76 IAMSWITZERLAND-1/09 — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 16:34:34 -0000

I agree with the Edward's POV thing as do most of the fans of the saga. It would add to their story and give us much more info about the Cullens as a whole (which my friends and I are very interested in).

Carlisle does speak about why it was so painful for Edward . . . he tells Bella it was because he didn't know what he was doing as it was his first time changing anyone. He had to go off the wounds that had been inflicted on his body and this was a very painful process for Edward due to Carlisle's inexperience. The fact that the more venom that is put into the person being changed the quicker the process goes is a trial and error process for Carlisle, something that obviously isn't perfected even when Bella is changed.

I think the context of sex is different than the whole birth scene for the publishers. Idk why . . . but I believe that Stephenie said in an interview that this is the reason she couldn't put a lot of details about their honeymoon in BD. She has also said that she was under immense pressure from her publisher to end the series with book 3 but went to book 4. I think she will eventually write more . . . once some of the pressure from the Twilight saga had died down a bit.

The cool thing about this Saga is that every reader takes away similar yet different things from it based on their own life experiences.

________________________________

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

tweeter76 IAMSWITZERLAND-1/09 — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 15:39:07 -0000

No way . . . I totally think it's healthy that she was moving on. It's what "normal" people do after a break up. It wouldn't have been such a moving and relatable story if Stephenie hadn't written it that way.

________________________________

Re: Kristen Stewart Talks about Supernatural Love Triangle

Cordelia — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 15:05:07 -0000

That happens in Eclipse and I'm talking about NM.