NewMoonMovie.org - Latest Comments in Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

anuj sharma — Thu, 23 Jun 2011 01:54:11 -0000

This is a best titanic movie in the world...free online movies..Watch all your favorite Movies and TV shows online for free...Watch-the-movies-online is a free movies online site where you can watch free films

free online movies

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

mindo — Sat, 02 Oct 2010 01:56:56 -0000

Leo wins for me by a landslide. No comparison!

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

lutz_of_love — Thu, 21 Jan 2010 10:38:08 -0000

Aw pimsy come back! We miss you!

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

brenda_bites — Mon, 09 Nov 2009 16:26:07 -0000

YAY...
thanks very much i am waving it like no tomorrow :D

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:16:11 -0000

He is! I loved him in Titanic! Who didn't? And he aslo has a new movie coming out, it looks really good. About psycho people or something. :)

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:15:12 -0000

**swoon**

So hot!!

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:14:44 -0000

Yep! But if I was asked back in the day, def Leo...Rob was a little..**cough** girly back then. lol

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:13:56 -0000

Exactly! And Summit knows they love us smutty yr olds! lol

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:13:02 -0000

I'm dying here!!!

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Guest — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:11:35 -0000

haha!! And BTW, congrats on being a blogger!!! So happy, yet so jealous! But mostly happy! lol :)

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Team Edward — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 14:27:27 -0000

Rob look so hotte rthan Leonardo Dicaprio or another way of saying his name Jack from Titanic. Anyways i fell in love with Jacok/Leo when he did Romeo and Juliet and Titanic but not anymore i got a new hunk/stud/hotty/sexy bad vampire!!!1 LOL.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Swjos — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 07:37:03 -0000

Swjos is fine, but you can also say Linda. :) Nice to meet you. ;)
Yes, I live in Germany, and when the TL DVD came out, I finally had the chance to watch the movie in English and did it ever since. I wish they would show more original versions here in theatres, so I could watch New Moon in english BEFORE the DVD is in stores.

You really brought up some interesting scenes there! I thought the office seen was just great! I think the "every time calmness" in the books made Edward such a flat and unrealistic character, so I think it was the right decision to "almost growl" there. I mean, he's almost desperate because of all the sudden bloodlust and his will to kill Bella. His world has turned upside down, because he can't even read her mind. And to be honest - Edward is a lame duck in social behaviour, if he can't read what others are thinking. ;) So I understand all his angryness.

I also think, Bellas reaction was fine with "put your seatbells on", because she's just stressed and confused and you say silly things like this, when you're really nervous. Just Robs laughing distracted me.

Hmm, the greenhouse scene... I don't know what to think about it. I see your point, now that you've mentioned it, but it haven't come up to me before. Maybe because I don't really like Edward and everything not-so-friendly he does feels like underlining my kind-of negatoves feelings for him.
See, I think this is the point that shows, that Rob indeed HAS acting skills. I like Rob and still don't like Edward. Which is why I love the Volturi scenes, maybe. :P

It's not really the world of the Twilight Saga I blame. You're right, the world - or let better say the unusual display of vampires - is nice to read. But as an author myself, I just have a loooot of critism about her story-development, writing style and especially character creation. Especially last part is the reason, why I prefere the Saga movies, other than usual. Above all, Kristen really "rescues" the whole Saga for me with her portrayle of Bella. :)

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

leakitties — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 21:52:31 -0000

No, he is absoloutely not snooty.

Look he was young and fun once too ;)

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

leakitties — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 21:47:02 -0000

Leo is not 36, he's turning 35 in a few days ;)

I am 24, I was a huge huge huge Leo fan (still am)... and Leo mania was CRAZY, absoloutely nuts. I think Leo mania was huger than Robs fan base, he had so much merchandise just for him, whereas Rob has more Twilight merch etc.

I think there's no comparing. Leo had his teenybop time and grew into a recognised wonderful actor, Rob is still in that teenybops screaming in his face phase, and he is more than 10 years younger than Leo. There's no comparing. I'm not saying Rob isn't a wonderful actor, he is and I am huge fan of his too and he's grabbed my heart like Leo did back in the day. But, you get my point.

It's impossible to compare their looks, charisma etc. Leo was also funny and cute and shy back then, he did adorable interviews and was known on set for being a little funny trouble maker... but now he's a much older man with more acting experience behind him.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 21:10:57 -0000

I thought the 'distract me' scene was off, too, but I think the scripting was to blame. Obviously they couldn't use the 'I'm gonna run over Tyler' talk - b/c they didn't have Tyler asking her to the dance and the dress shop talk in the movie - but I think MR should have come up with something better than 'put your seat belt on' - What was that??

I never really thought much on the scene when he realizes James figures it out - but I guess I can see that. Really my only criticism of Rob in TL is sometimes he seems annoyed and angry when he's supposed to be smooth and calm. For example - in the office when he's trying to change classes and Bella walks in - he almost growls, "I guess I'll just have to endure it!" That should have been in his pleading velvet voice, "That's ok, I see there's nothing that can be done. Thank you." Then when Bella stumble on the field trip he seems angry and annoyed that she can't even walk without hurting herself. In the book he laughs at her clumsiness and jokes that she is a very difficult person to keep alive. Again - most of this could be blamed on scripting - but he definitely didn't have the tone right.

I have very high hopes for the rest of the saga movies and Rob's future career in general - I think he's going to be great.

You really confused me with your SM comment - I love the world of TL she has created and I also loved The Host. If it weren't for my total addiction to her writing - I wouldn't be on here. I have never followed any other fan site or had any obsession this deep.

I think your English is great! Do you live in Germany? I have a good friend who is Russian and she's been in the states almost 2 years. Her English is pretty good, but she still has a hard time reading/writing in English. She liked the TL movie, and I thought about ordering the book in Russian, but never did. I've heard the translations leave a lot out. Have you seen TL in English? Guess you have to wait on the dvd for that, huh?

BTW, what to I call you? Swjos? I'm Shannon, or SC

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

spiritwolfJRS-*TeamTentScene* — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 18:10:35 -0000

Yes, that Taylor. Here is a recent pic of Taylor and Zac

http://tinyurl.com/ycytnoq

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Swjos — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 14:08:13 -0000

*grrr* Just posted a looon reply and newmoonmovie ate it for breakfast...
Here we fo again...

The first really ruined scene is the one in the car, with Edward and Bella. Edward driving awaay fast from the bad guys, asking Bella to sidetrack him. Edward is suposed to be full of anger and bloodlust and killinginstinct here. But what Rob shows is a reaction like.. sorry, like he has to use the bathroom. If I've been Hartwick, I would have ask him to do this take again.

Second really ruined scene was not only his fault, but Kellans and Nikkis as well. When the tracker (James) changes direction... I still don't get why they all stood still at once and start staring. It feels so unreal...

The scene where he drinks Bellas blood isn't really good as well, but I can deal with it. But you now what? The scenes where he is really GREAT are the extended and deleted once... which makes me feel like Rob can do scenes better, where Edward os happy (forest) or insecure (all the rest of the deleted scenes).

After all, I'm still a Rob fan, because I like the way he behaves and because he seems down to earth. Still I'm critic about his acting skills. He has to learn a lot more, and I think he eventually will, as long as he gets roles he can grow with.

By the way, I dpn't thin I'm influenced by reading the books frist, because ... well, I'm a passionate reader, but I don't like Meyers books because of several reasons.

Oh dear, sounds like I have to whine about anything... which is not, normally. ;)

Please excuse my bad English. I'm from germany. Which means, I have to stand Kristens and Robs sychron voices in a few days and THEY really ruin a lot of scenes and acting skills. :(

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

amyhall — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 12:38:47 -0000

Jack and Rose had a few days on a ship and a social/economic dilemma in their relationship. Bella and Edward have immortality and months of near death experiences, their story was much more tumultous than the Jack/Rose storyline. Leo is pretty, dates selectively and acts a little snooty. Rob has an amazing sense of humor, an amazing level of self-awareness and is dirty hot, not just "pretty". Let this not be a subject of debate again... seriously.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

rhythmchyc — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 06:53:27 -0000

Haha, Andrew Keegan. Every time I think of that guy, I think a** from 10 things I hate about you LOL.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Shannonsparkles-Teambreakrecs! — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 06:48:54 -0000

Nope. was never team Leo...... sure he's a talented actor, but he just doesn't have that charisma or that depth to his eyes to be able to rock your world with just a look. Rob has that look down to a science. I did have posters of Andrew Keegan though, when I was like 11 years old. But, yeah, no other celeb hearthrob nears having half the appeal that Rob does.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

rhythmchyc — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 06:41:30 -0000

Hey were you in the "Mrs. Leo Dicaprio" bandwagon at all? I just never understood it.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Shannonsparkles-Teambreakrecs! — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 05:41:33 -0000

totally agree. It's all in the eyes.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Shannonsparkles-Teambreakrecs! — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 05:39:17 -0000

I know! I went to the bookstore today, and was SHOCKED to see the huge Twilight Saga display is no longer front and center when you walk in the door. I was even more shocked, when after walking around for 10 minutes, there was not a single Twilight Saga book to be found. Finally, when I had all but given up, Rob's face caught my eye from a wall far away. They had a display set up in the KIDS section! Ridiculous. Seriously, most of the hardcore fans are adults. Where did the mix up occur?

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

Whysper — Fri, 06 Nov 2009 01:21:47 -0000

your right Leo isnt Rob....Leo is sooo much more! I was a teen during Leo mania and saw Titanic many times over... I even had the movie ordered through QVC before I had even seen it lol. My whole walls were covered with Leo :) ... Even today Leo is still one of my favorite actors. I love Rob.. but his hygiene habits (or lack there of) scare me.

Re: Leonardo DiCaprio VS. Robert Pattinson: Vanity Fair’s Heartthrob Smackdown

cutesweetiezzz — Thu, 05 Nov 2009 22:40:14 -0000

Stop with the comparison already. Rob is Rob and Leo is Leo. So there!