NewMoonMovie.org - Latest Comments in New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

rosaline — Wed, 26 May 2010 20:36:19 -0000

its not a comment i have but a question. i wanted to know if bella stays with edward collin or dose the wolf guy keep her. im not much of a reader so i havent read the book.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

H2B — Mon, 05 Apr 2010 21:15:29 -0000

What a shock MR actually did something right.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

EmmettLover1 — Sat, 01 Aug 2009 11:10:57 -0000

I dont know why but I think Rob should get I COOL hair cut and then more people would like him.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Ashley — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 21:41:56 -0000

The whole idea behind midnight sun was to include Edward's POV but because of the leak it is something fan's will never get, and shouldn't be included in the new moon movie. This book is about Bella and Jacob's relationship and how she develops herself and her character through her loss, if Edward's POV is constantly shown then that development seriously risks being lost. However the spirit guide may work, as Bella 'hears' Edward's voice when she does something dangerous, a translucent image of Edward whispering may work.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Ashley — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 21:40:21 -0000

the whole idea behind midnight sun was to include Edward's POV but because of the leak it is something fan's will never get, and shouldn't be included in the new moon movie. This book is about Bella and Jacob's relationship and how she develops herself and her character through her loss, if Edward's POV is constantly shown then that development seriously risks being lost. However the spirit guide may work, as Bella 'hears' Edward's voice when she does something dangerous, a translucent image of Edward whispering may work.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Twilight_nerd — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 17:09:28 -0000

i'm not saying i don't like the book, i do. i've read them over ten times each. i'm just saying that, anything that we imagion while reading, would be next to imposable for them to put on screen

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Twilight_nerd — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 15:51:20 -0000

STOP COMPLAINING THE MOVIE WILL COME OUT HOWEVER IT COMES OUT. AND IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT THEN TUFF! JUST GO READ THE BOOK AGAIN. WE ALL KNOW THAT THE WAY WE SEE IT COULD NEVER BE PUT INTO A TWO HOUR MOVIE SO THERE IS NO POINT IN f****** COMPLAINING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

alyssa — Sun, 31 May 2009 18:03:19 -0000

there are so many ways they could give pattinson more screen time without going too far away from the book. for example, bella "hears" edward's voice a lot when in times of danger. so, instead of just hearing him, they could have edward standing behind her saying everything. it's not like she has to be looking at him or anything. it's just like a physical representation of what's going on in her head. it makes the adaption from the book a lot easier for the cast and crew when trying to shoot those scenes while staying as real to the book as possible. also, he could have a lot of face time towards the end, like in alice's visions.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Dmitrii — Tue, 26 May 2009 04:28:37 -0000

That is SUCH a good idea. Veiwing new moon as bella and edwards point of view; Know whats going on with both of them. Thats very good

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Coltney — Sat, 23 May 2009 23:37:05 -0000

Well, I think to those of you who say that it will be boring watching Bella being depressed, I feel sorry for you, because that's the book. I do agree that liberties must be taken. that fact that there is the Italy scene and the whole "you killed my mate" coming from Victoria, i dont see how they can fit it in in less that 2 hours. I say lets Lord of theRings this sucker and make it 3, 3 and a half. I dont think any of us fans would have a problem with that, ey? Weaving Edward in more is smarter though, I think in the book steph is trying to get across, that her obsession is worsening, the opposite of what Edward wanted, and that yes, Jake is gradually filling that hole, but that makes it even worse for her. Having him in every other Dream Sequence would really show how depressed she was. With the wolves, I have seen some clips and what not, in my mind while i was reading New Moon i imagined them MUCH bigger, judging by how tall and huge these guys get, I would think the wolves would be monstrous, not normal sized wolves. I dont know, thats just me. Anyways, those are my thoughts, I think someone needs to get ahold of the director and knock some sense into him!

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Jamie ( girl ) — Thu, 21 May 2009 17:55:29 -0000

OMG, i love twilight, iIf she's smart she will leave Edward in and out of the story while he's gone with what he is doing while he is gone (with Stephenie Meyer's help of course). He says in the book that he tried "tracking" as James was a tracker, and he tried that on Victoria because he knew she was still out there somewhere, but inevitabiy lost her. That was the one thing I remembered him telling Bella he was doing. They could also show him leaving how he left his family for a while because he was so miserable and didn't want to inflict his pain on others (I think?). There are good ways they can keep him in the limelight still during the movie without being unfaithful to the book... by showing Edward's perspective along with Bella's during that time frame of their lives

am worried about Melissa Rosenberg's script of New Moon given what she did with Twilight. I understand the film adaptation never lives up to the actual book. But the most important scenes and dialogue that were integral to establishing Bella's & Edward's passion, love, and commitment to each other in the book were either completely altered or removed from the movie. There was no build-up of passion in the movie at all. The filmmakers should have stayed faithful to Stephenie's vision in Twilight. There's is no need to "simplify" the plot, or "add" more action. Why have fans fallen in love with the saga? It's the emotional connection that Stephenie created with her characters...not just Bella and Edward, but with all the other characters as well. That is what the filmmakers need to capture and convey on screen. And that will only work with a well-written script that stays true to the books. There is an interview on Twilight Lexicon with Melissa Rosenberg, the screenwriter for Twilight and the sequels. She admits she "had very little contact with Stephenie initially" and she wanted to bring her "own vision to it." We are watching these movies expecting Stephenie's vision...not Melissa Rosenberg's vision. So many fans, myself included, were saddened and disapppointed by the film's treatment of pivotal scenes from the book, like the meadow. I truly hope Stephenie insists
that the sequels do justice to her books and her devoted fans.

This is a hard one to answer really. For one, I totally agree on them staying true to the New Moon book most definitely. But at the same time, who really wouldn't like to see more of Edward in it. And I do not think that New Moon was slow. Stephenie Myer took us to another level of her creativity. New Moon is about Edward trying to do what he thinks is best for Bella. And if it wasn't for Jacob Black then who knows what the outcome might have been for Bella and Edward. I do agree that they should definitely keep the ending the same. The yellow porsche and all ! ! ! But at the same time I think the director should let us see how Edward was really handling the choice he made. Oh, one more thing. I'm going to miss Catherine Hardwicke for sure!!

Written by Jamie,

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Ilecra — Tue, 19 May 2009 19:44:35 -0000

After reading the Midnight Sun, I had a second thought of Edward not really leaving Bella in New Moon. As you all know, Edward could not live without seeing Bella even for a second. He's madly in love with her. He left her so that he could fulfill his mission despite of the fact that his decision would also hurt him tremendously. It was a sacrifice that he needed to do for Bella's sake. I am glad to hear that the scriptwriter and director of New Moon have tweaked the screenplay by adding more scenes of Edward...hoooray!!!

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Renessme — Mon, 18 May 2009 08:29:09 -0000

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

blank — Thu, 14 May 2009 01:54:49 -0000

All of you need to keep in mind that the Twilight series are all in Bella's perspective...not Edward's. If Stephanie Meyer wanted the readers to know what Edward was doing while he was away, she would have added his perspective into the plot line. Twilight was about Edward and Bella's growing relationship while New Moon is about Jacob and Bella's growing friendship. Having the audience know that Edward is still protecting Bella from a distance and is completely miserable with totally distract the audience from Bella and Jacob. Jacob wouldn't even have a fair chance with the audience. Rob Pattinson is going to be within the entire movie, but he will be in dreams and hallucinations. His POV will not be discussed until the very end.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

jenny — Tue, 12 May 2009 15:03:31 -0000

I do not think that is necessary to put more Edward. Jacob Black is more than enough. New Moon is about him and Bella.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

maggy — Tue, 12 May 2009 14:58:57 -0000

I think we should see more of Jacob Black. He is so hot and my favorite character in the whole saga. I even think that bell should end up with Jacob. He loves her more than Edward ever could. He would of never left her.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

katrinaSAURUS — Tue, 12 May 2009 13:06:46 -0000

I think the directors should just say true to the book and not really change anything, because the readers wouldnt want to see a movie that is barely like the book. So I don't understand why they have to change and add all these scenes that had nothing to do with the book what so ever, it just wouldnt make sense. [i read all the books, and new moon was just very depressing because yes edward left bella & that was just sad cause she was so lonely & trying to figure out why]. Catherine Hardwicke did a very good job at directing it but in a lot of ways she ruined it by adding scenes that didnt belong and didnt exactly fit in, she might've tried to put it all together but it really had nothing to do with twilight. So I am hoping that the new director will make a better movie, and not ruin it for us readers.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

sarah — Sat, 25 Apr 2009 11:30:10 -0000

They've confirmed that Edward will feature a lot in this but the majority will be in Bella's dreams.

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

twilightlover — Thu, 23 Apr 2009 21:57:38 -0000

i agree with missy people only come to the theaters to see the romance bewteen edward and bella if you change that ......then yes less people will want to see the movie if you wanted to see romance bewteen jacob and bella the first book would be called new moon

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

britt britt — Thu, 23 Apr 2009 21:27:58 -0000

i am kind of exited for new moon but i was heart broken to find out that bella and edward broke up and half the book is about jacob i just hope the movie does not change to much or i am done with this twilight thing i hope the new director will keep the ending the same...........................................

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Immortallove — Wed, 15 Apr 2009 15:45:53 -0000

I agree. I really hope the movie stays true with the book. The old director did okay but there were a few things I think could have been added, or taken out, or changed. Hopefully this new director doesnt do too much with the movie. No matter what, I trust the cast and im still extremely excited!

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Lamb. — Mon, 13 Apr 2009 18:43:58 -0000

okay. i agree with more edward. but lets stick with the book. i hate when movies go soo off track. there can still be edward in it. i mean look at all the times bella hears his voice! go with tiny flashbacks of when he said that to her in real life. it would be simple. if they go jacob all the way no edward till the end i will walk out! it will be boring and stupid. as for alot of jacob, there has to be! he IS like the whole book. getting to know jacob. and yes we need to see bella's pain but not the months of it, just go like the book.. like just show the month and show 2 seconds of bella crying for each month. people will get the picture. its not that complicated really. just look at it literally. go by the book and everything will be AMAZINGG!!!!

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Danni — Mon, 13 Apr 2009 18:33:08 -0000

they dont have to do that. They can do exactly what stephanie did in the book. January, Febuary, March ect. u see what im sayin it doesnt have to be like that

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

Arabella Cullen — Sat, 11 Apr 2009 00:27:45 -0000

Alot of people are getting an idea that New Moon will will limit Rob/ Edward character i read on one of the article that they want to keep the story closer to the book but instead of using Rob's voice/ Edward they will use an images of him. And almost have of the book anyways was mostly spend on Bella and Edward. Son no worries its always a misconception we all need to read the new moon book 6 times for us to really understand the story, I hated Jacob when i first read the book and i even skip his alot of chapters in the book because i was looking for Edward/Bella being together again. Then when i got to Eclipse, breaking dawn i realized i need to re read it again to understand very well. Support NEW MOON or else we won't be seing Breaking Dawn

Re: New Moon Script Finds a Way to Upsize Edward Cullen

vampire/werewolf09 — Thu, 09 Apr 2009 16:41:03 -0000

if they change the movie 2 where there is more edward then they need 2 change the name of the movie because it WILL NOT BE NEW MOON!!!!!!! i love edward and i hated him not being there but tht is how it is and i had to get over tht and so does everyone else!!!! they cant take away jacobs time 2 shine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love edward but i enjoyed bella and jacobs friendship after i gave it a chance :) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yes i know new moon is despressong and sad but edward COMES BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!! new moon is NOT team edward its team jacob!! and you people who want it changed need 2 GET OVER IT!! because thts how stephenie meyer wrote and she didnt write tht way for it 2 be changed when its made into a MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!